Kulturkompasset | critics of culture events

TURANDOT at Torre del Lago Puccini


di Giacomo Puccini at Torre del Lago Puccini,

Turandot. CASOLLA. Foto Puccini Festival

Turandot. CASOLLA. Foto Puccini Festival

Gran Teatro all’aperto Giacomo Puccini, 2015 august 23rd

Review by Fabio Bardelli

Torre del Lago Puccini/ITALY: We should start this review by the end of Turandot, as it is well known that Puccini was unable to complete the opera because of the illness that led him to the grave. Publisher Ricordi commissioned Neapolitan composer Franco Alfano to complete the work basing on notes left by Puccini himself, even if the version currently performed in Italian houses is a second version by Alfano, but with interventions and cuts by conductor Arturo Toscanini.

Turandot. three masks and their double- 2nd act. Foto Puccini Festival

Turandot. three masks and their double- 2nd act. Foto Puccini Festival

In 2001 there was the first performance of a new final composed by the contemporary Italian musician Luciano Berio. This final appears to be particularly interesting and quite respectful to Puccini’s notes concluding the work in pianissimo as he wanted instead of the usual grandiloquent final by Alfano.

Puccini himself left on a sheet related to the final the words “And then Tristan”, to mean that he would conclude the opera in pianissimo as Wagner’s masterpiece. Certainly the final by Berio is much more internalized and resolves better the notorious scene of the “thawing” of the Princess and the following kiss using a modern musical language, but I think that it fits perfectly in poetry and fairy-tale suspended background of the work catching its atmosphere and probably coming closer to what Maestro Puccini wanted.

Turandot. Park (Calaf) and the Three Masks  Ping Pang Pong. photo Luca Ramacciotti

Turandot.  Rudy Park (Calaf) and the Three Masks Ping Pang Pong. photo Luca Ramacciotti

Puccini Festival Foundation after announcing the performance of all the existing finals in the various performances of this production (Alfano, Alfano-Toscanini, Berio, and the unfinished opera as left by Puccini having as last scene Liù’s death) has unfortunately opted for the more reassuring and traditional final, the Alfano-Toscanini, for all the performances.

We regret this very much, it would be very interesting to compare on stage the various finals, and this choice could certainly be a jewel of the crown in Puccini Festival. Anyhow the management of the Festival has changed over in last months, many artistic and gestional problems follow one another, and the decision that was taken is to perform only the traditional final.

Turandot. Mandarino Claudio Ottino, foto Ramacciotti

Turandot. Mandarino Claudio Ottino, foto Ramacciotti

The staging of Angelo Bertini (besides director also author of scenes and costumes) is really interesting, full of imagination and quite functional

cardiovascular diseases such as aortic stenosis should- a focused physical examination should be performed What is sildenafil citrate?.

. A staging to remember, with a legendary and visionary China as we all expect, colorful imaginative and a bit surreal costumes, even if with some “excess” for example in transforming the three Masks almost in puppets, or changing the Mandarino in a kind of drag-queen ante litteram. Some visual schematism and some superfluous ideas, for example to show Princess’s beheaded suitors as ghosts wrapped in white sheets, or children Chorus on stage instead of behind the scenes, don’t diminish the value of a really well-made staging. Very accurate was the light designing by Valerio Alfieri.

Turandot. Rudy Park (Calaf) left, and  Casolla (Turandot (right. Foto Puccini Festival

Turandot. Rudy Park (Calaf) left, and Casolla (Turandot (right. Foto Puccini Festival

Bruno Nicoli is a long experienced conductor who performs the musical score with agogic and timbric choices that are above all functional. Who would expect from the conductor great interpretative ideas could perhaps be disappointed, but surely he is quite able to rule correctly the singers and the stage in a work certainly not easy to perform as Turandot. We have to note, in a generally functional orchestration and conducting, some tension loss such as in the first scene of Second act, besides very well staged by director Bertini showing the home in Honan and the blue pond, a dream environment where the “double” of the three Masks act.

Turandot.  Casolla (Turandot) Foto: Luca Ramacciotti

. Casolla (Turandot) Foto: Luca Ramacciotti

Soprano Giovanna Casolla has still a surprising artistic career, her debut was in 1977 and her large repertoire includes difficult soprano and mezzo roles. Turandot is a short part but very difficult, and the Neapolitan singer comes out heads up
. Her character is well depicted, Mrs Casolla’s voice is still large in volume, her phrasing is imperious, and some inevitable hardness and intonation slips can be forgiven.

. Casolla (Turandot) (left) at, liù's funeral 
. Foto Puccini Festival

Turandot. Casolla (Turandot) (left) at, liù’s funeral. Foto Puccini Festival

Rudy Park is the classic summer arenas tenor with a stentorian muscular voice, showing sure and large top notes, but the phrasing is monotonous and predictable, his attempts to lighten the voice are scarce. His “enflate cheeks” in the long run is tiring, anyhow he had a great success, even encoring his air Nessun dorma.

Soprano Valentina Boi in possess of an important voice rich with nuances, she delineates a character a bit different from the usual clichés of a tender and plaintive Liù to give us a strong-willed and passionate girl. Growing from the First to the Third act, the young singer from Livorno is really exciting as well as scenically very credible.

Turandot. Curtain call. Photo Simone Tomei

Turandot. Curtain call. Photo Simone Tomei

Among the three Masks (Nicolò Ayroldi, Orfeo Zanetti and Gregory Bonfatti), overall very effective, we must praise young baritone Nicolò Ayroldi, a well educated and really promising voice.

Bass Luigi Roni as Timur is at present completely inaudible, the scarce fragments of what was once a voice are not certainly enough to make him outline with honor his character.

Claudio Ottino was a mediocre Mandarino, midlevel the other singers in minor parts, with the exception of a very questionable Altoum sung by Massimo La Guardia, really embarrassing.

The public was rather large and warm in applause with all the artists specially with Mr Park and Mrs Casolla.


Direttore d’orchestra, Bruno Nicoli

Regia, scene e costumi, Angelo Bertini

Light Designer, Valerio Alfieri

Assistente alla regia, Luca Ramacciotti

Orchestra e Coro del Festival Puccini

Maestro del Coro, Stefano Visconti

Maestro del Coro delle voci bianche, Sara Matteucci

Turandot, Giovanna Casolla

Calaf, Rudy Park

Liù, Valentina Boi

Timur, Luigi Roni

Altoum, Massimo La Guardia

Ping, Nicolò Ayroldi

Pong, Orfeo Zanetti

Pang, Gregory Bonfatti

Un Mandarino, Claudio Ottino

Prima Ancella, Francesca Borrelli

Seconda Ancella, Sofia Nagast

Principe di Persia, Roberto Ferraro

Tagged as: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,